data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f9720/f97204e8a7028a00f4b630538f7035bd380824de" alt=""
The guy inside the fish market is, as you may have noticed, talking to nobody.
Also, Heathcliff is a rather poor salesperson. He's the one who steals fish. Why sell insurance against that act if he's the perpetrator.
Somebody needs to explain insurance to Mr. Gallagher.